BLENDER OR JUICER: PICKING THE PERFECT MACHINE FOR YOUR NEEDS
Deciding whether to juice or blend is a choice that depends upon what you want to achieve. If you just want to add some nutrients to your diet along with some fiber, then blending will suit your needs perfectly. If your goal is quick absorption of large amounts of nutrients, or if you want to undergo a cleansing experience, then juicing is the way to go. Here are a few more points to consider when making your decision:
• Juicing requires very little digestion, so if you are experiencing problems with fiber (due to illness or otherwise), then juice is the best way to increase your nutrients without stressing your digestive tract.
• Smoothies require additional digestion to extract the nutrients from the plant fibers, but the fiber helps with elimination on its way out.
• Juicing is a more concentrated, rapid source of nutrients, because the nutrients are readily available, and you can drink much more because there’s no fiber to fill you up.
• If you’re one of those people who hate to eat green vegetables, then juicing is a great way to get all of your daily nutrients in just a few swallows.
• Some professionals postulate that the chewing action required by food is a necessary part of the digestive process, so according to that theory, if you’re drinking a chunky smoothie that requires a bit of jaw action, you may be taking the healthier route.
• If your goal is a complete cleanse, fiber is usually discouraged so the body can use the energy it saves from the digestive process to heal and cleanse, thus making juice the best option.
When it comes right down to it, the decision to drink juices or smoothies (or a combination of the two) depends upon your goals. If you’re healthy and just want to add some extra nutrients into your diet, then smoothies are a great idea. If you don’t like the texture of ground fruits and veggies, are short on time, or want the extra burst of nutrients without feeling full, then you may prefer juice. As with all decisions about your body, do your research and make an educated choice based upon what’s personally best for you.
Whether you’re making a juice or a smoothie, you’re going to need a good piece of equipment to take your produce from chewable to drinkable. There are dozens of different blenders and juicers on the market, and what kind you need depends upon a few different variables, including:
• How often are you going to use it?
• What are you going to be blending or juicing?
• How many people are you using it for?
• How much space do you have?
• How quiet do you need it to be?
• How much money do you have to spend?
Since there aren’t quite as many factors that go into buying a blender as a juicer, and you can get one for a fairly decent price (usually under $100), let’s review the blender choices first.
What to Look for in a Blender
A blender is a blender, right? Wrong. There are as many different blenders out there as there are things to put in them. The choices can be overwhelming, and there are some things to watch out for that you might not consider as a first-time buyer. That’s why we’ve gone to longtime smoothie makers to find out what problems they’ve encountered, to ensure that you avoid those pitfalls on your journey to the perfect smoothie. Here are a few of the top tips that should help you on your way:
• Try to stick with metal blades and internal parts, avoiding plastic, especially if you’re going to be using your blender frequently.
• Anything under 500 watts probably won’t be effective.
• Choose a blender with at least two different speed settings, plus a pulse function, because it’s best to start on low to chop, then work your way up through the speeds to get the finest consistency with the least amount of nutrient-killing heat.
• Look for products with warranties, and buy your blender from stores that stand behind their products. It’s frustrating to invest good money in a blender just to have it break two weeks later, only to find out that the company or store won’t stand behind the product.
Blenders range in price from about $20 to well over $500, but there’s really no need to go to the top for a machine that meets your needs. That being said, a $20 blender probably won’t do the job, at least not for very long. If you’re serious about making smoothies, it’s best to invest in a good blender that will last, rather than buying several cheap blenders over time that continue to break — and have no warranty.
Some Good “Smoothie Blender” Suggestions
A few excellent choices broken down by price include:
$300+ Range: The best in form and function
• Vitamix 5200: 1000 watts, powerful 2 HP motor, 64-ounce carafe, 7-year warranty, BPA-free carafe, variable speed dial as well as the ability to pulse, plus a patented tamper so you can quickly blend even thick ingredients.
• Blendtec Home Pro Choice Total Blender: 1500 watts, 3 HP motor, 64-ounce carafe, lifetime warranty on blade and coupling, 3-year warranty on base, 29K RPM, 6 blending options plus pulse. Features Smart-Touch Tec-nology© that automatically speeds up and slows down as necessary and shuts off at the end of the cycle.
$200–$300 Range: Top quality
• Breville 800BLXL Hemisphere: 1000 watts, 67-ounce polycarbonate carafe, uniquely shaped carafe, blades that allow for zero dead space around the edge of the carafe, 1-year limited warranty, 2 speeds plus pulse.
• Cuisinart CBT 100 PowerEdge: 1000 watts, 1.3 HP motor, BPA-free carafe, 3-year limited warranty, high and low settings plus preprogrammed smoothie, pulse, and ice-crush settings that intermittently speed up and slow down for best results.
$100–$200 Range: Very effective
• KitchenAid KSB560MC Blender: 720 watts, 0.9 HP motor, 56-ounce polycarbonate carafe, 1-year replacement warranty, 5 speeds plus pulse.
Under $100: Great value for the price
• Oster Beehive: 600 watts, 40-ounce glass carafe, 1-year warranty, 2 speeds plus pulse.
More expensive isn’t always better, but in the case of these blenders, you really don’t want to go with anything under $50. Most likely you’ll just be wasting your money on a product that’s not going to work well and will only break within a few months. Spend the extra money and do it right!
What Type of Juicer Is Right for You?
Most of us have used a blender at some point in our lives, so purchasing one isn’t completely alien territory. When it comes to juicers, however, it’s like learning a whole new language. They often look awkward, and figuring out exactly what all of those pieces are for is an exercise in physics. Yet there’s no need to feel intimidated; we’re going to clear up any confusion and give you a preliminary sense of what to look for on your search.
Did You Know? Juicers come in six basic styles: centrifugal, masticating, upright masticating, twin gear (aka triturating), wheatgrass, and hydraulic press.
Buying a juicer can be a major investment, so knowing the facts about the equipment prior to making your purchase is only smart. Each type of juicer is great at producing the juice for which it’s been specialized, but buying one that doesn’t meet your overall needs can be an expensive, messy mistake. Let’s break these down and discuss the pros and cons of each.
• Centrifugal Juicers are the least expensive juicers on the market and the type that most department stores carry. They extract your juice by shredding the produce and then using centrifugal force to spin the pulp against a strainer at extremely high RPMs. This is OK if you’re juicing soft produce, but these machines produce much more waste (wet pulp) than other types of juicers.
Pros: Speed and affordability.
Cons: Low efficiency (high waste); decreased shelf life, because the extraction process spins oxidizing air into the juice; and difficulty juicing grasses or leafy produce.
• Masticating Juicers extract juice by literally “chewing” the food using a single auger or gear and then separating the juice as it chews. This process results in more nutrients, fiber, and enzymes being extracted from the pulp because of the chewing action.
Pros: Greater efficiency, less air in the juice, more nutrients extracted from the produce, and less nutrients lost due to heat or oxidization, because it operates at a lower RPM than a centrifugal juicer. Also, masticating juicers often do a good job with leafy greens and grasses. Many masticating juicers also homogenize your produce, so you can make baby foods, ice cream, sauces, or nut butters.
Cons: Higher cost, larger size, and more noise. A masticating juicer also takes significantly more time than a centrifugal juicer does.
• Upright Masticating Juicers have all of the benefits of a typical, single-auger masticating juicer but are designed to operate in an upright position in order to be more space-efficient. There are also a couple of design differences. Instead of being chewed and extracted, the juice is squeezed out first, then the pulp is crushed and pressed again in a second phase to extract even more juice.
Pros: Higher juice yield and less waste, a smaller space requirement, and less waste due to heat or injected air. They can capably juice just about anything.
Cons: Significantly higher cost, and they’re often noisy.
• Triturating (Twin Gear) Juicers extract juice in much the same manner as a masticating juicer, except that they squeeze the pulp between two interlocking gears. Because they’re designed to be slow and powerful, these juicers crack the nutrients from the cells, so not only do you get a higher yield of juice, you get more nutrients, too. Triturating juicers are typically the most expensive juicer, but because you can do so many things with them and they produce so little waste, they’re worth it if you can swing the cost.
Pros: The higher juice/nutrient yield, less waste from either heat production or the extraction process, the ability to efficiently juice grasses and leaves, and the capability of the machine to homogenize in order to make baby foods, nut butters, ice creams, sorbets, and even pastas.
Cons: High cost, greater space requirements, and more time due to slower RPMs.
• Wheatgrass Juicers do exactly what the name implies: juice grasses. They aren’t designed to juice anything other than grasses, with the possible exception of a few small, soft fruits, such as grapes. These juicers come in both manual and electric styles.
Pros: The fact that you can get an efficient, affordable model if all you’re looking to do is make a nice green shot for health reasons or to add to a recipe.
Cons: It’s an expensive piece of equipment given its specialized, limited capabilities, and the fact that they’re often bulky. Especially considering that most decent juicers can handle leafy greens and grasses, this isn’t a necessary piece of equipment for green juicing anymore if you buy a suitable standard juicer.
• Hydraulic Press Juicers also known as Norwalk Juicers, extract juice in the most efficient way possible: they literally press it out. There’s no chewing or grinding of the produce, and there’s extremely little waste. Also, since it’s a simple pressing process, there’s no heat produced, or air forced into the juice. It’s far and away the best way to extract juice.
Pros: Practically no waste, no damage to the juice, and no air pressed in to cause oxidation.
Cons: Extremely expensive at around $2,500 and take up a large amount of space — great if you have the room and the money, but unrealistic for most of us.
Choosing the right juicer or blender is an important part of your experience, so educate yourself about your options and choose wisely. Because there are so many different brands, and people juice for so many reasons, it’s difficult to make specific product recommendations, so just pay attention to what the various machines offer and match those features to what you intend to use most.